Monday, March 10, 2008

First Concept: Cause and Effect Diagram


Cause and effect diagram is used to find the cause of a problem. We choose it as one of our solution model’s tool because it can help us to identify the causes of our problem. Our problem is the usage of many papers by students, based on our topic which is “Paperless Students’ Life on Campus”.
We divide the causes into four part : manpower, machines, materials and methods.
Under the manpower section, we find that the causes are negative attitudes of students towards the usage of papers, lack of awareness among students about this issue and requirements of lecturers about paper works. Students play very important role in solving this problem. Students should take their initiative to reduce usage of papers. They have to concern and sensitive to this issue. It will be more effective if the lecturers also put their effort in solving this problem. Since there are many inventions of educational technology, lecturers may use those tools in their teaching methods. Using those technologies, it is not impossible to implement paperless technique in education.

In the machines section, we find that the technology is not in advanced. The internet that students use is slow and not stable. The range of wireless connections is also not wide so that sometimes it is difficult to access into learning. Besides, there are students who are not afford to buy personal computer which is expensive and the maintenance cost is also high.

In the materials section, we find that most of the usage of papers come from the workloads of students such as the assignments and lecture notes. Some of the students do not full-used their papers and misuse the papers.

In the methods section, we find that our education system is the cause. Our education system can be improved to reduce the usage of papers. More technologies can be used in teaching and learning methods.

Discussion on Operation Systems and Concepts Used to Create Solution Model



From the above diagram, it is shown that the solution model that we use incorporated with three concepts of operations management which are Cause and Effect Diagram, PDCA cycle and Electronic Data System (EDI) under lean system.


Cause and Effect Diagram defines the cause of problem. PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act ) cycle suggests and implements the solutions. Electronic Data Interchange under Lean System used to solve the problem. The cycle rounds again to improve better and greater.

Analysis of Survey Question 10:


10. As a student, what you think you should do in order to create a paperless environment if the teaching method in campus still use a lot of papers?

a. Discuss the issue with the lecturers
b. Reuse papers for printing assignments or notes
c. Just follow the requirements of lecturers
d. Others_______________________

The Pareto Chart above shows that most of the students can create a paperless environment in USM campus if the teaching method still use a lot of papers (unchanged) by reusing papers. However, there are also a large number of students will follow the lecturer’s requirement to use papers without taking any own initiative to create a paperless environment. Around 20% of students are brave enough to discuss the matter with their lecturers whereas 4% of students will use other method.

Analysis of Survey Question 9:


9. Which way do you think is the most effective to create awareness among students about paperless concept?
a. Peer influence b. Brochures c. Campaign d. Talk e. Other __________


From the Pareto Chart above, we can see that the largest number of students agree that peer influence is the most effective factor that can create awareness of paperless among students whereas the lowest frequency of students agree that other factors are effective in creating awareness. Almost 30% of students agree on campaign, 12% agree on talk and 9% agree on brochures can create paperless system awareness respectively.

Analysis of Survey Question 8:


8. Have you ever get involved in any activities that will lead to a paperless student life on campus?

a. Yes b. No

Until now, there are only 20% of students from our survey have involved in activities which promote paperless whereas a large number of students; 80% have not involved in any paperless activity.

Analysis of Survey Question 7:


7. Do you think paperless student life can be implemented fully in campus?
a. Yes b. No


In students’ opinion, there are only 23% of students agree that paperless system can be implemented fully in USM campus. In the other hand, there are 77% of students think that paperless system cannot be implemented fully in USM campus.

Analysis of Survey Question 6:


6. In what way do you think you can reduce paper usage?

a. Upload assignment on internet b. Download lecture notes
c. E-learning d. E-communication e. E-examination


The pie chart above shows that most of students; 45% agree that e-communication can reduce the usage of papers to the minimum. However, there are only 6% of students agree that downloading lecture notes can minimize the usage of papers. For other ways to reduce papers usage, there are 25% of students agree on uploading assignment on the internet, 14% agree on e-examination whereas 10% students agree on e-learning.